Traditional vs Roth 401K: Understanding How They are Different

Traditional 401K vs ROTH 401K

One of the not-so-easy decisions many American workers face today is choosing the right type of 401K to contribute to so they can minimize as much taxes as possible. Luckily, we have an expert that can chime in for you.

Rick Pendykoski is the owner of Self Directed Retirement Plans LLC, a retirement planning firm based in Goodyear, AZ. He has over three decades of experience working with investments and retirement planning, and over the last 10 years has turned his focus to self-directed accounts and alternative investments. Rick regularly posts helpful tips and articles on his blog at SD Retirement as well as, SAP, MoneyForLunch, BiggerPockets, SocialMediaToday, and NuWireInvestor.

One thing that can significantly affect your long-term and retirement savings is the type of employer-sponsored retirement plan you choose. While traditional 401(k) plans and Roth 401(k) sound similar, there are some major differences between the two accounts.

It is important to understand the difference between the two so that you can select the one best for you.

Traditional 401(k)

This is a tax-deferred method to pay for retirement. All your retirement contributions and matching funds from the employer will go into your account before the taxes. This reduces your tax bill by lowering the taxable income.

You won’t have to pay taxes until you start making withdrawals. The withdrawals can be done by the age of 59½, all of which will be penalty-free. You must start taking minimum distributions from a traditional 401(k) by the 1st of April of the year after you turn 70½, or if later, the year in which you retire.

Roth 401(k)

A Roth 401(k) has the opposite tax setup than that of traditional 401(k). You will use after-tax money to fund the contribution. However, your contributions and the earnings grow tax-free, provided you don’t withdraw the funds before the age of 59½.

There are no income limits, therefore, you can make Roth 401(k) contributions no matter how much you earn, as long as you earn a salary. Secondly, you need to start taking the minimum distributions the year after you turn 70½.

Regardless of whether you are contributing to a traditional 401(k) or Roth 401(k), the total IRS 401(k) contribution limits are $18,500 a year if you are under 50 and $24,500 a year if you over the age of 50.

Traditional 401(k) vs Roth 401(k)

Let us understand the differences between traditional 401(k) and Roth 401(k)

Traditional 401(k)Roth 401(k)
Tax for contributions All the contributions are made pre-tax. This reduces your current adjusted gross income.The contributions are made after taxes and there is no effect on the adjusted gross income. The employer matching funds go into a pre-tax account and are taxed when distributed.
Tax at WithdrawalsAll the distributions in retirement are taxed as ordinary income.There are no taxes on qualified distributions in retirement.
Withdrawal RulesThe withdrawals of contributions and earnings are taxed. You will be penalized if the distributions are taken before the age of 59½, unless you meet one of the IRS exceptions. The withdrawals of earnings and contributions are not taxed as long as the distribution is considered qualified by the IRS, namely:
a) The account has been held for five years or more
b) The distribution is due to a death or disability or on/after the age of 59½.

Unlike Roth IRA, you cannot withdraw contributions at any time.

Choosing Between Traditional 401(k) and Roth 401(k)

The decision of choosing between Roth 401(k) and traditional 401(k) boils down to how you want to put the money into the account. Additionally, it also depends on how you want to withdraw the money.

When to choose Traditional 401(k): If your primary goal is to reduce the taxable income now or pay the taxes after retirement because you believe that the tax rate will go down.

When to choose Roth 401(k): If you prefer paying the taxes now or believe that the tax rate will be higher in retirement than what it is now. By paying taxes now, you would be protecting yourself from a potential increase in tax rates when you retire. However, there is a chance that your taxable income may drop and put you in a lower tax bracket.

In Conclusion

Once you understand the difference between Roth 401k vs 401k, you can decide which 401(k) account will give you better returns. Consider your retirement goals and current financial situation as well to reach an informed decision.

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What is your retirement number?
End of the Year Question: What is Your Retirement Number?

If I were to pay you to quit your job, how much would it be? Is it $1 million, $3 million, or nowhere near these numbers? Many think you can no longer retire with $1 million because of inflation. This may or may not be true depending on your spending …

This sheet tells you when to get out of the shit hole
This Sheet Tells You When to Get Out of the Shithole

One of my favorite movies of all-time is American Beauty. The 1999 award-winning film stars Kevin Spacey who played Lester Burnham, a 40-something guy who hated his job and was on the brink of a mid-life crisis. The inflection point was when he saw his daughter’s gorgeous 16-year-old cheerleader friend, Angela Hayes (Mena Suvari), perform during a half-time dance routine at a high school basketball game.
Lester becomes so infatuated with Angela that he began having sexual fantasies with her. He becomes obsessed with youth that he started to live his life like he just graduated from high school. And when he was told that he was about to get laid off, he instead blackmailed his boss for $60,000. He then quits work anyway choosing to work as a crew in a fast-food chain instead– the position with, in his own words, the least amount of responsibility.
But what really caught my attention is the scene where Lester Burnham wonders in his cubicle while seeing a reflection of his image on the monitor, which resembles a guy trapped in a jail cell. With the numbers on the spreadsheet forming the jail bars in his mind, it’s pretty obvious that he felt imprisoned by his job and wanted an escape. A feeling that many people can sympathize.

Benefits of Tax-Advantaged Savings
Tax-Advantaged Savings and Recommended Strategies

According to the National Study of Millionaires by Ramsey Solutions, 8 out of 10 millionaires invested in their company’s 401(k) plan, and that simple step was a key to their financial success. Not only that but 3 out of 4 of those surveyed also invested outside of company plans— mostly …