Stupid Money Mistakes my Smart Neighbors Make (Part I: Private Schools)

Stupid money mistakes my neighbors make (Part 1: Private Schools)
Relationships
7

One of my goals in writing this blog is to help you become smarter with money. You’d think it’s just common sense. But as it turns out, common sense is not so common.  Otherwise, people wouldn’t buy things they can’t afford. They wouldn’t smoke cigarettes or eat junk food either.

To become smart involves a lot of learning. We read authoritative articles over the web, or maybe books written by experts, for example. But in many cases, we learn from our own mistakes. After all, your experience is the best teacher, right?

Not really, it’s actually better to learn from the mistakes of others–myself and my neighbors included. You don’t want to overdose with heroin to learn that the drug can kill you– it will be too late at that point. Learning the hard way is completely optional.

Of course, this is not to make fun of my neighbors. Everyone makes mistakes. It’s the act that’s stupid not necessarily the people making it. I’ve blogged about my own dumb mistakes before. But this series is about the dumb mistakes my neighbors made or are still making. I’ve masked their true identities to protect the innocent, but the details are factual.

“Learn from the mistakes of others. You can’t live long enough to make them all yourself.” – Eleanor Roosevelt

Paying for private school for the sake of religion

A few of my neighbors are also Filipino-Americans. Like me, they were raised as Catholics. I’ve given up Catholicism years ago, but I’ve stayed very close to my neighbors who happen to be my friends. They belong to a closely-knit Catholic community headed by a parish priest who is widely respected and revered. My neighbors were strongly encouraged to enroll their children in the parish school where education is interwoven with their faith and traditions.

Because of their religious beliefs, they all sent their kids to the local Catholic school that can cost up to $5,000 per child. That’s $400 per month that they could have contributed to a tax-advantaged college savings account. Had they, from the very beginning, invested that money aggressively in 529 accounts, they would have enough money to pay for their kids’ college education.

I actually suggested the idea when we had a gathering over a decade ago, but it was quickly dismissed with a smirk. Now some of them are scrambling to find loans and potential scholarships when they should have prepared for this a decade ago.

Where I live, public education, especially its popular alternative– charter schools, is decent and completely free. Well, sort of, as homeowners, we pay substantial property taxes and a huge percentage of these taxes are allocated to fund public schools. So we might as well take advantage of the services that we’re actually paying for anyway.

Don’t get me wrong. Sending your kids to private schools per se is not dumb. Sending them when you haven’t saved for their college education is. Paying for private schools when you haven’t paid off your own student loan debt is even dumber.

I can understand the parents desire to instill the same religious values to their children. But providing a “bubble” like atmosphere is not the way to go. Someday their kids will leave this bubble and interact with various types of people.  They need to prepare their kids for the real world.

And by the way, the local priest has been charged for raping a girl and recording their sex acts.

Letting their kids decide where to attend college

At a recent gathering, I had a conversation with a neighbor friend of mine who I haven’t seen in weeks. It turns out that he and his wife have been busy driving their daughter out-of-state to college open-houses to know more about the schools she’s interested in applying to.

“Elaina just got a $15,000 scholarship at Georgetown University, renewable for four consecutive years!” he exclaimed.

“That’s awesome! What major does she intend to take?” I replied.

“Bachelor of Science in Nursing” he answered back.

“Are you paying for the rest?” I replied knowing that Georgetown University is one of the most expensive universities in America. There’s no way $15K can cover the entire tuition amount.

“No way, she’s the one who wants to go there. She’ll figure out a way to pay it off,” he replied as if there’s nothing he can do about it.

Immediately, I felt sorry for 18-year-old Elaina. Even with a $15,000 scholarship, the annual total cost could easily reach $50,000 if you include on-campus room and board, and other expenses. That’s a $200,000 investment if you’re lucky to finish the course in four years.

Is the $200,000 private education worth it? Absolutely not, my wife is a BSN and she knows for a fact that employers don’t really care where you completed your degree, let alone how much you spent for it. You can obtain that degree for a small fraction of that– around $10,000 per year in a nearby university, much less with scholarship and grants. And she doesn’t even have to pay for room and board as it is completely within driving distance.

No parental intervention

That’s a $200,000 decision, why on earth would they as parents decide to not intervene?? In general, 18-year-old kids are naive and inexperienced. They have no inkling of what it takes to pay off a $200,000 student loan debt. They can easily be enamored by the nice facilities offered by these overpriced American educational institutions.

The problem is the enormous amount of risk an innocent 18-year old will have to assume to obtain this education. Unlike credit card debt, student loans are not in any way dischargeable by filing bankruptcy. It follows you like a monkey on your shoulder.

The worst that can happen is she gets sidetracked by some unexpected event like a debilitating injury rendering her unable to work.  Or she can end up eloping with her boyfriend before completing her studies.

Not probable if she’s focused, but still possible. There’s no shortage of possibilities, the parent should have intervened!

When my eldest son applied to different colleges several years ago, I accidentally opened a letter that was addressed to him (he’s my junior– we have the same first name). It was a letter of acceptance from a prestigious private school that costs about $40,000 a year. At the time, he was already set to go to an excellent in-state public university that costs less than half as much. That letter went straight to the trash can.

I’ve kept it a secret all these years and have no regrets whatsoever. You can call me controlling, but at least I’ve intervened. I’m the one paying, not him. Besides, that public education didn’t stop him from getting hired at IBM.

By the way, he’s only 25 and already debt free. Unlike the millions of Americans who are struggling to pay student loan debt today.


In part II, we’ll talk about my neighbor’s stupid car payments.

Great points you raised there. I think religion may be the worst reason to send your kids to expensive schools. In any case, I dream of the day when the quality of teaching in Philippine public schools (especially in grade and high schools) improves to the extent that we won’t be afraid of sending our kids there.

That’s very true. I wouldn’t send my own kids to public elementary schools there– especially in rural areas where classes are sometimes held under a mango tree. The quality has deteriorated due to chronic underfunding– maybe because of the administration’s messed-up priorities or corruption. Americans should learn how to appreciate their public school system. They have no idea how good it is relative to other countries. Thanks for commenting.

It’s good to know that Americans can go to college without spending that much so I wonder why students choose to bury themselves with debt.

Living overseas in Canada for years, I am impressed with the free public schools and library. Everything is free in the library; I can even access online courses for free instead of paying monthly. With these opportunities, if I were a young student, I probably wouldn’t have gone to college. I’m better at studying online; I’m clueless as to how I sat for so many years in a classroom.

And if only kids in the Philippines would be given the opportunity to get a loan to finish their education, I bet walang magbubulakbol (they wouldn’t miss a class). Usually, parents pay for their kid’s tuition fee; maybe, that’s why most of them weren’t able to save for retirement.

I am now shocked how much is the tuition fee in a university. How can parents afford to send there kids to school to get a degree if not everyone can go to state universities. Good thing there are options like TESDA; it’s practical nowadays to take trade courses to fill the demand in worldwide economy.

Kudos for your son not having debt and you for paying his tuition. Will wait for more dumb mistakes to learn from.

Thanks for commenting. I heard Canadians pay a bit more taxes than Americans so that probably explains why. Were you talking about tuition fees back home? The problem here in the U.S. is that people don’t shop around because of the myth that student-loans are “good debt”. I have a friend who went to great lengths shopping for a laptop PC for his college-bound daughter, spending precious time driving to another state, 40 miles away, just to avoid paying sales tax. Yet he wouldn’t stop a second sending her to a very pricey university– essentially trying to save money on something that doesn’t really matter! If only people could apply the same degree of diligence to picking a school they can truly afford, we wouldn’t have a student loan crisis today.

I can understand the urge to do the best for your children – but the costs involved are sometimes ridiculous.
The benefits of a private education are there – but it is not good value for money.
The cost does not make it worthwhile and I think that it is more a case of virtue signalling and keeping up with the Joneses.

Similarly, we have a Nanny at the moment to allow my wife to go back to work and to look after our son. It costs MORE than a nursery and it’s hard to justify from a frugal point of view but it’s worth it for his development.
Nurseries are not cheap either but the Nanny does a better job – and for a child, the first couple of years development are more important than anything else. If you skimp on the early years, no amount of private school tuition will makes up the difference

Everybody’s situation is unique. In your case, the return of investment is probably high as she enables your wife to go back to work. And you seem to be very intentional with your money having a “Monthly Assets & Spending” plan. My neighbors seem to just follow the flock.

7 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Why Married Couples Who Combine Finances Get Richer
Relationships
2
Should You Marry for Love or Money? Why Not Both?

If you are reasonably attractive, your shortest path to wealth could be to marry for money. But should you? The old joke is to marry some rich old man (or woman) and marry for love after they die. But that only makes you a glorified prostitute. Since Valentine’s Day just …

Xbox Christmas Wish
Relationships
How to Teach Your Xbox Obsessed Kids About Money and Investing

My son once told me he someday wants to earn big bucks working for Microsoft. “So you want to be a software developer like me?” I asked. “No, I want to be a cashier; that’s where the money is!” he quipped. That’s when he was nine. Kids this age have …

Position of F--- You
Career
2
Being in a “Position of F— You” Gave Me the Power to Say No

What is the best thing about being financially independent? It puts you in a “Position of Fuck You.” Once you have enough money, you don’t need a boss— nobody can tell you what to do. Or, if you wish to remain employed, nobody can tell you where to do your …

%d bloggers like this: